Is this a pure cachinnans?

[vuelvepiedras]

Hello gullers,

would like to ask your opinions about these 2 gulls. Photographed yesterday at Malaga harbour, Spain, by Salva Garcia.

Is this one suitable for a pure cachinnans?

06012014-_MG_4906.jpg (144.05KiB)Viewed 2168 times

06012014-_MG_4918.jpg (158.51KiB)Viewed 2169 times

assa4.jpg (98.67KiB)Viewed 2169 times

assaqw.jpg (145.83KiB)Viewed 2169 times

In adition, this "monster", same place, same day.

1479001_1407885739453031_1314855280_n.jpg (119.32KiB)Viewed 2169 times

1601144_1407885716119700_736072225_n.jpg (79.02KiB)Viewed 2169 times

Thanks in advance for your opinions.

Gabi, Madrid.

[lou bertalan]

hi gabi,

both look good for pure cachinnans, even with the concentration of "pencilstreaks" around eye. scapular pattern is one of the variations caspian gull can show and greater covert and tail pattern are good as well.

good gulling 2014!

lou