4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

User avatar
marsmuusse
Posts:666
Joined:Sun Sep 27, 2009 12:43 pm
Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by marsmuusse » Sat Nov 01, 2014 7:38 pm

One of the potential problems is that we may have a bias in W Europe (or in Europe in general?) looking at cachinnans. But of course this is a very old taxon (one of the two source populations in Europe) and subsequently will show a large variation in its phenotypics. Here a link to what many (including myself probably) would label Yellow-legged Gull michahellis, if not ringed as pullus. It's the most famous cachinnans of Poland (in Jacek's words)...
http://gull-research.org/cachinnans/5cy/006p.html
Larus cachinnans adult green 006P January 12 2007 & January 06 2008, Woerth, Niederoesterreich, Austria. Picture: Wolfgang Schweighofer.

Image

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Sun Nov 02, 2014 4:12 pm

sorry to answer again on the same topic.
Quite the opposite, Lou, it's highly appreciated!
2 looks a bit like YLG indeed with its crisp pattern but you can't exclude a 2cy cachi with a bit bolder markings.
In western France, the concern doesn't really lie in excluding a possible cachinnans when one watches a michahellis, but the reverse!
note for instance the strong bump behind legs in the 2nd pic - uncommon in YLG.
Not so strong for me...
4. - don't share your concerns about the 'globular head' and short bill - everything abs. within variation of good casp. gull.
Very OK with you after all.

Any other opinions?
Everybody's OK with 3. & 4. '1st cycle cachi', 2. & 5. possible YLG or 'strange birds', and 1. too blurry to tell?

Thanks & regards,
Emmanuel

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Sun Nov 02, 2014 4:33 pm

what many (including myself probably) would label Yellow-legged Gull michahellis, if not ringed as pullus. It's the most famous cachinnans of Poland
Everybody here would have just seen a YLG in this bird (standing or flying) and not reacted at all (I assume) as before a CG.
And without such a ring, it would never have been approved as a CG...

Few authentic Dutch people may really look like good Greek people... even if very few indeed.
(and may even become famous! ;o)

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Wed Nov 05, 2014 1:51 pm

Hi, a new bird from last Sunday in Calvados, Normandy.
A specially typical one for me (Gibbins's score = 17, indeed!?).
Upper parts' moult very similar to http://gull-research.org/cachinnans/1cy/dn09082.html - 1 GC + 1 MC!
However, this new Tony's bird has whiter head and longer legs: good boy!

Eventually, are all previous birds good caspians to your eyes, except 2 possible/probable cachinnans x argentatus hybrids (if not YLG)?

Regards,
Emmanuel
Attachments
IMG52279-304red - TLHN 021114 Dives.jpg
Tony Le Hu Nghia 2/11/2014 Dives-sur-Mer (14-F)
IMG52279-304red - TLHN 021114 Dives.jpg (215.93KiB)Viewed 7336 times
IMG52286-97red2 - TLHN 021114 Dives.jpg
Tony Le Hu Nghia 2/11/2014 Dives-sur-Mer (14-F)
IMG52286-97red2 - TLHN 021114 Dives.jpg (160.28KiB)Viewed 7336 times

lou bertalan
Posts:503
Joined:Tue Nov 03, 2009 2:43 pm
Location:stuttgart, SW germany
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by lou bertalan » Wed Nov 05, 2014 3:10 pm

hi emmanuel,

the new guy looks perfect. but as for 006P i'm quite sure it is not a pure cachinnans (no deep tongues in outer primaries...) but probably a micha x cachi. some YLG are always around in black sea and they breed on crimea which is not too far from azov sea...! http://gull-research.org/cachinnans/5cy/006p.html

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Wed Nov 05, 2014 6:17 pm

the new guy looks perfect.
Thanks again Lou!
but as for 006P i'm quite sure it is not a pure cachinnans
A DNA testing would have been very relevant or instructive for this bird... (nearly 15 years old now: still alive ?!)

Bonsoir !

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Sat Nov 15, 2014 4:14 pm

Hi, below is another probably good Caspian from Normandy (5/09, ringed in Reddern/D, 7/06/2013).
The observer only asks for some comments before he sends his report to the regional Committee...

I add a new "brochette" from yesterday in Dives-sur-Mer, Calvados (cheers again to Tony Le Hu Nghia).
Two 2cy (one well-known yet) + one 1cy. Traffic is getting bigger.

Have a good WE,
Emmanuel
Attachments
XLDW - Ouistreham 050914 JPM red.jpg
Ouistreham 05/09/14 JPM
XLDW - Ouistreham 050914 JPM red.jpg (84.62KiB)Viewed 7288 times
3 pontiques Dives 141114 TLHN red.jpg
Dives 14/11/14 TLHN
3 pontiques Dives 141114 TLHN red.jpg (173.23KiB)Viewed 7288 times

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Mon Nov 17, 2014 1:32 pm

Hi friends, any comment about the 1st bird above (05/09/14) ?

lou bertalan
Posts:503
Joined:Tue Nov 03, 2009 2:43 pm
Location:stuttgart, SW germany
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by lou bertalan » Mon Nov 17, 2014 9:43 pm

well, it can well go as pure 2cy cachinnans but, stemming from reddern - hard to know for sure if there is some HG involvement or not.

Emmanuel
Posts:17
Joined:Tue Oct 07, 2014 6:33 pm
Location:Rennes - Brittany - France
Contact:

Re: 4 birds: pure Caspians or...?!

Post by Emmanuel » Wed Nov 19, 2014 3:46 pm

Thanks again Lou,
But as Ronald explained, Gräbendorfer See (Reddern) is the most recent and supposed pure. The mixed colony is Sedlitz.

However, the following bird (Ouistreham 16/11/2014) could stem from this second dubious place...
At first sight, it looks like a YLG (common at this date). But the bill doesn't do it, the backwardness in moult either.
Short wings, streaks on head and chest, unmoulted scaps and mantle, lack of ventral bulge, some pattern on external GC, could evoke argentatus blood.
The rest reminding of cachinnans: bill, long tibias, tertials, combed look of coverts, shape in front...
On Gibbins's famous table, the score reaches 25 or 26... which tends to confirm a CGxHG hybrid, while saying nothing in relation to YLG, alas!
What do you think, larophiles?

Regards,
Emmanuel
Attachments
leucoJPM1-3red.jpg
Ouistreham 16/11/2014 JPM 1
leucoJPM1-3red.jpg (229.89KiB)Viewed 7249 times
leucoJPM2red.jpg
Ouistreham 16/11/2014 JPM 2
leucoJPM2red.jpg (138.91KiB)Viewed 7249 times

Post Reply